Tuesday, January 8, 2013

FIFA awards are a joke




Here we go ladies and gentlemen. The Ballon D'Or and FIFPro are one big fat joke. You want to know why? Of course you do.

Firstly, let me start off by saying congratulations to Lionel Messi (because I know he checks this website every single day before heading to training). No one else deserves the trophy more than him. The man is a magical footballer. Often I criticize many aspects of Barcelona and I get some not-so-friendly responses, but when it comes to Messi I think there is a universal agreement that he is the best player in the world at the moment (click here to know why I think you can't have a "best team/player of all-time"). He's an incredible player.

Secondly, as I began seeing the news flood in about the FIFPro team of the year and the Ballon D'Or trophy itself, I realized (not for the first time and not on my own), just how much of a joke FIFA are at times. I'll start with the Ballon D'Or trophy itself. And before you start calling me names (I'm looking at you Barcelona fans), here are a few things you all probably didn't know about the Ballon D'Or:

  • The original Ballon D'Or trophy (a.k.a European Footballer of the year) was an annual award presented to the best European (that's the key word in here) footballer of the previous year. Its inauguration was in 1956 and its end was in 2009. Yes, what Lionel Messi is winning is the same "trophy" (that golden ball that looks like it's worth more money than we'll ever know), but it's not the same award. The criteria have changed.
  • Up until 1995, the original Ballon D'Or (1956-2009) could only be awarded to European footballers. Meaning that players like Diego Maradona, Pele, Zico, Socrates, Valderama and thousands of other South American (and other continental) legends were ineligible for the award! So for all those making a huge deal out of Messi winning it four times in a row, my answer to them is - yes, it's a remarkable achievement, but can you imagine if all those legends I just mentioned were candidates in their prime? Don't you think one of them would have gotten it the same (if not more) number of times? I'm thinking particularly about Pele and Maradona who had absolutely no competition to them at the time for quite a while!
  • In 2009, the original Ballon D'Or and the previously prestigious FIFA World Player of The Year (which players from all around the world could be candidates for and that started off in 1991 and was stopped in 2009) merged to become the "FIFA Ballon D'Or". This means that all of a sudden, the history books have disregarded the FIFA World Player of the Year which some non-Europeans had won and that prior to the original Ballon D'Or & the FIFA World Player of the year - there was no single international individual trophy out there that could or would recognize players that were NOT European!
  • The only individual trophies that players like Pele and Maradona were eligible for were things like "South American player of the year" and other awards that have no credibility in the Football world today. If that is not a travesty, I don't know what is.

Basically, the point I'm trying to make is that despite the fact that Lionel Messi is an amazing footballer and deserves those 4 Ballon D'Ors, please don't disregard how the Football history of awards has changed.

Now onto my next point and please nobody take this personally (Barcelona, Real Madrid and La Liga fans, again - your fury can chill a bit. It's an opinion. Think logically and you might see that I'm right). But seriously, how on earth is the entire FIFPro team made of 11 La Liga players. Yes, La Liga is a competitive league and all that, but come on. 11 players from La Liga! Here are some points about that:


  • The team selected was: Casillas, Alves, Marcelo, Ramos, Pique, Iniesta, Xavi, Alonso, Ronaldo, Messi, Falcao.
  • Who votes for these players? Well, it's the players themselves. Basically, every single professional footballer in the world votes and then FIFPro take the votes and do the counting. It always has to be a 4-3-3 formation.
  • So the large majority of players around the world decided that no players from the Premier League, the Bundesliga, the Serie A and Ligue 1 warranted a place in the team?
  • Unless, I'm bloody mistaken, but either footballers are complete retards (highly likely) or FIFPro have somehow chosen the players they would rather have licking them (even more likely). Let's go over each player. One by one.
  • Casillas' inclusion can't be debated. A close second would be Gianluigi Buffon. Both, along with Neuer are the 3 best goalkeepers in the world at the moment. Thank God they didn't choose Victor Valdes. It could have happened you know.
  • Dani Alves as the best right back in the world? Highly debatable. But that's not because he's any good at defending, but just because of the luxury he has of playing with such talent alongside him. Put him in any other team in the world and he'd struggle. Just count how many times he's out of position when Barcelona are faced with a "challenge" - if you can call it that in a match. He is their weakest link (along with Valdes).
  • Marcelo at left-back is completely wrong. I still think Ashley Cole is a better left-back than him. I don't know how they choose the players, but Cole won the Champions League and the FA Cup and despite the fact that he's a complete tw*t that I hate, I believe he's been the most consistent left-back over the past 10 years in Europe. Think of him as a footballer, not as a person. If the votes are based on achievements during the year, Cole should get the nod.
  • Sergio Ramos and Gerard Pique are the central defenders. What a joke! Not only are both incredibly overrated defenders, but there are loads of other defenders in Europe who've had a better 2012 than them. I hate Manchester City more than most, but surely Vincent Kompany is better than both of these players and had a better year. You can't judge their yearly performance solely on Euro 2012. It has to be throughout the year. And besides for Kompany, I think Giorgio Chiellini (Juventus' defender who helped them go undefeated for the whole of last season and was a key member of the Euro 2012 final team) and Matt Hummels (2 Bundesliga titles in a row and a bloody rock at the back) also deserve those spots much more than those two fancy models from Spain.
  • Xavi and Iniesta - no complains there. World class again.
  • Xabi Alonso ahead of Andrea Pirlo might be the biggest crime of all. How was this judgement made? Based on form? I don't think so. Pirlo was arguably the best player at Euro 2012 and the best player in the Serie A last season, so again this might be a selection based on the fact that Alonso won the Euros. Which, if it is the case, is a damn shame. Alonso is a very good player, but this is not a popularity contest.
  • Lionel Messi. Legend. Cristiano Ronaldo. Legend. I don't think we'll know their true value until they've retired.
  • Radamel Falcao is a superstar. I love the player. Had the privilege of watching him live a year and a half ago and he was mighty then, just as he is now. The only striker that I think should be put in this team ahead of him is Robin Van Persie. I'm not sure who can help me find a statistic, but I do believe RVP has scored more goals than Falcao in the calendar year (I might be wrong).
  • Coach of the year: Mourinho, Del Bosque and Guardiola were the nominees. So Antonio Conte, who went a whole season undefeated didn't even make the grade. Del Bosque winning the Euro was a great achievement, but seriously winning Coach of the YEAR for a tournament that lasts a month (winning 5 games in the process)? Hell, even Roberto Di Matteo deserves a mention following his miracles last season with Chelsea, not to mention Jurgen Klopp who won the double for the first time in Dortmund's history. 

All in all, barring the decisions on Messi, Ronaldo, Casillas, Xavi and Iniesta, everything else is extremely debatable and laughable. I can't understand the FIFPro team, nor can I understand the coach of the year award. The Ballon D'Or choice was obvious, but the story of Messi winning 4 in a row tells half of it. Put your allegiances aside and try thinking objectively. This is not a popularity contest. These are awards that, and unfortunately are re-writing the history of our game.

4 comments:

  1. Then you've got the fact that somehow, not a single player from 2 Champions League finalist squads merits a mention in the FIFPro XI.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mess is Spanish, he was granted the spanish citizenship in 2005.

    ReplyDelete
  3. weightloss
    The Wellness Store - Quick & Easy Ordering From Your Independent Herbalife Distributor & Personal Wellness Coach
    weightloss

    ReplyDelete
  4. Try to find pleasure in the speed that you're not used to. Changing the way you do routine things allows a new person to grow inside of you. But when all is said and done, you're the one who must decide how you handle it

    ReplyDelete